I am a fan of the SIX model of revenue: you pay to connect to the exchange up front and bigger ports (ie 10-Gig) cost more than smaller (ie 1-Gig). This fee applies to MICE core equipment only. Port costs on extension switches are dictated by the respective extension switch operators.
As there are already many existing connected ports I would also be in favor of retroactively charging each connected port based on their current port type(s) in use at the time of the implementation of said fees. Already connected organizations that want to take a bit of time to budget can make arrangements with the board. Also, I would be in favor of implementing this soon instead of waiting for the desired but elusive non-profit status unless someone has knowledge of its actual pending completion.
I feel this method alleviates the problem of non-payment induced disconnects, switch port reservations, tracking payments, etc. I don't know the history of other exchanges with regards to disconnecting organizations, freeing up port and IP number resources, but clearly sometimes companies go under or otherwise have a change in strategy and no longer desire to be connected yet do not formally announce they are disconnecting. So to that end, after some period of time (X months) of being in an unreachable state via their IXP IP addresses, a disconnect is implemented unless said organization otherwise scheduled or coordinated with MICE to be offline for an extended period of time. I am guessing there is some historical data available from other exchanges or other best practices that could be used to guide us on how to do this.
With regards to gaining membership/voting rights I like the notion of requiring an active port connection to the exchange (core or extension) with an ASN and reachable exchange assigned IP address(es). An alternate method of gaining membership/voting rights would be from serving on the board of the exchange which would not require one to be an already connected organization of the exchange.
Summary of member voting eligibility
Provides Eligibility to Vote:
* Elected board members. Board members may or may not represent a connected organization, I assume the bylaws cover the 1-vote max per organization but that is implied here
* Connected organizations with ASN and at least one reachable exchange assigned IP number
Does Not Provide Eligibility to Vote:
* Sponsors, 3rd parties, etc (eg Cologix, operators of extension switches)
* Organizations exclusively using ancillary exchange services (eg pvlans)
________________________________
From: MICE Discuss [[log in to unmask]] on behalf of Steve Howard [[log in to unmask]]
Sent: Thursday, September 15, 2016 7:22 PM
To: [log in to unmask]
Subject: Re: [MICE-DISCUSS] Proposed Membership and Sponsorship Model
I'm a little "late to the party" for this discussion, but I'd like to add a few of my thoughts:
First off, I'd like to thank Dave for coming up with great ideas and points for discussion.
MICE is a cooperative (not a charity). As a cooperative, we need to treat everybody equally. I feel that everybody should have to pay membership dues at some level, perhaps an amount based upon port size. If we fail to require the payment of dues, we will have different classes of users and the potential for discontent as some people don't pay their fair share. Like Martin said, "Classes create inequities". If people don't pay, they need to be disconnected (after a reasonable grace period). The dollar amounts due will likely be very small, the exchange has gotten by without any payments required for several years. I don't think that the fees that would need to be charged would be anything that an organization connecting to the exchange cannot absorb. If they can't handle ~$9/month (using Dave's example numbers), they won't be around long in this industry.
I agree with Richard Laager's points about enforcement. We need to enforce whatever policy is decided. I don't like any scenario where the board might have the option to waive fees. That will create the feeling of the "good 'ol boy" system.
I also think that all newly connected members should get their initial connect period free, primarily as a sales tool. I'd like to give new members a chance to "try before you buy" to see if it works for them. Perhaps we bill annually and they don't pay until the next billing cycle starts (or some variation thereof)? Until they pay, they should be subject to their port being assigned to somebody else, not be official members, and not able to vote.
How do we handle members that are connected to remote switches? Is the switch owner the member? The downstream users? Both? Who pays the port charges? Only the switch owner?
Steve
On 09/08/2016 01:05 PM, David Farmer wrote:
I'm not a candidate and will not be a candidate for the Board. However, I propose the following Membership and Sponsorship Model, including both Membership Dues and Sponsorship levels for MICE Members and Non-Member Sponsors.
The dollar values are just my suggestions, I think they should work but they are primarily intended to illustrate the model.
With this Model, any network may connect to the Exchange, but all networks participating in governance, known as Members, will have some minimal skin-in-the-game. Further, the Model implies Networks with 10G or larger ports probably should participate at a more significant level, but this is not a requirement for access to 10G or larger ports or even to participate in governance.
The Friends of MICE Sponsorship level is intended to be accessible to anyone interested, including individual users of the Internet.
My proposal;
As an Open Internet Exchange any network with a uniquely registered Autonomous System Number (ASN) may connect to MICE. However, Non-Member networks are provided ports on the Exchange on an as-available basis only and Non-Members do not participate in the governance of the Exchange or the MICE Organization, but may observe and participate in its discussions.
Networks connected to the Exchange, or Data Centers hosting an Exchange switch, may become Members and participate in the governance of the Exchange and the MICE Organization by paying Membership Dues at either level listed below. Members are provided prefered access to 1G Exchange ports, and are provided access to 10G or larger Exchange ports on an as-available basis.
Sustaining or higher Members are committed to sustaining and growing the Exchange by electing to pay Sustaining Membership Dues and/or paying Basic Membership Dues and providing other Sponsorship to the Exchange of a value totaling $1000 or more. In recognition to this additional commitment, Sustaining or higher Members are provided prefered access to 10G or larger Exchange ports.
Basic Membership Dues - $100
Sustaining Membership Dues - $1000
(Dues are paid in cash or cash equivalents only, and may not be provided through in-kind services or equipment)
Beyond Dues from Members, MICE accepts Sponsorship both from Members and Non-Members Sponsors as cash, cash equivalents, in-kind services or equipment. Sponsorship is recognized at the following escalating levels based on the total value provided annually.
Friends of MICE - Sponsorship of $50 ore more annually
Sustaining Members or Sponsors - Sponsorship of $1,000 or more annually
Silver Members or Sponsors - Sponsorship of $2,500 or more annually
Gold Members or Sponsors - Sponsorship of $5,000 or more annually
Platinum Members or Sponsors - Sponsorship of $10,000 or more annually
Sponsorship of $20,000 or more are recognized with multiple years at the Platinum level.
Friends of MICE are list on a page on the MICE website. Sustaining or higher Members are annotated as such in their listings on the MICE website. All Sustaining or higher Members and Sponsors are listed on the MICE website, with higher levels receiving more prominent placement. Silver or higher Members and Sponsors are recognized in MICE marketing materials, with higher levels receiving more prominent placement.
Thanks
--
===============================================
David Farmer Email:[log in to unmask]
Networking & Telecommunication Services
Office of Information Technology
University of Minnesota
2218 University Ave SE Phone: 612-626-0815
Minneapolis, MN 55414-3029 Cell: 612-812-9952
===============================================
________________________________
To unsubscribe from the MICE-DISCUSS list, click the following link:
http://lists.iphouse.net/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=MICE-DISCUSS&A=1
________________________________
To unsubscribe from the MICE-DISCUSS list, click the following link:
http://lists.iphouse.net/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=MICE-DISCUSS&A=1
